First, the post title. I don't know many people who don't have a few song lyrics that they chronically mishear - often for years - until somebody corrects them. So there's that old Moody Blues song that includes mention of letters I've written/never meaning to send. For more than a decade I thought this song lamented never meaning to send LETTERS UNWRITTEN. And wtf was up with that?!? Many times I asked that question (but only of myself) until the evening a music geek in my writer's group made it clear I was WRONG in my "conveniently moronic lyric distillation chamber". Thus a core aspect of the chapter I was writing would have to be completely re-worked. Because it hinged on an internalized protagonist's rant based upon the sheer idiocy of letters unwritten. Why would you write them, after all, if you had no plans of sending them? Etc.
I felt a kissing cousin form of cognitive dissonance when I first saw the book pictured above. It was on the display rack of new non-fiction and I grabbed for it even though I was thinking I thought that quote went the other way around. Who said it anyway? Maybe I dreamed it. Etc. This book started its life as a doctoral thesis - a fact which is explained (along with a choice to invert a Thomas Dorsey quote. So I wasn't crazy! And hadn't been dreaming!) in the book's preface.
I'm not finished yet but I can say this about Buzzy Jackson's writing. She does something that many cannot: writes about music (the blues, no less) in a way so it breathes and you hear it with your mind's ear - hear it until you thirst to put the book aside and just go listen for awhile. I, for one, never get tired of Etta James. Even a little bit.
Buzzy covers some ladies I wouldn't necessarily consider blues singers (e.g. Joni Mitchell and Courtney Love) but I haven't gotten that far yet so I'm not going to quibble with her vision and how it's been articulated. Each chapter looks at a singer or two and some specific social/political time correlations with blues birth and development. Buzzy was a history major and it shows. I loved settling deeper into this book as I realized the full nourishing scope of it. Really loved how well the material 'co-operates' with the writer as well.
My favorite sections so far come from the chapter on Billie Holiday. There is a critical word-by-bar examination of Lady Day's signature closing song, Strange Fruit, that's absolutely as riveting as the song itself. I read those pages a few times over so I could "get" the words contextually but also so that I could savor it as a shining example of VERY well written evocative prose. The thing is, with a song like that and it's inarguable impact level, you don't really have to be evocative. But it sure don't hurt none.
Elsewhere in the same chapter, Buzzy considers the differences in personality between Bessie Smith and Billie Holiday - their very different singing styles that are borne from said personalities. There was just enough psychology and deductive supposition to intrigue rather than baffle or frustrate the historical focus. I honestly do think that writing about music is one of the hardest forms of writing because you really do need to evoke a sense of auditory participation somehow. Or else ramble on 'evocatively' enough but to the point where readers are focused on your Way With Words (hello, Greil Marcus...) rather than what, presumably, inspired you to work those words in the first place.
I put this book aside when Tony got home for Thanksgiving - in the middle of a chapter that compares Tina Turner and Aretha Franklin. Have not yet had an opportunity to get back to it but that will need to change as it's already nearly a week overdue at the library. Don't like to hog the books this way but it isn't chronic for me. Am, however, known for renewing everything.
I do, also, like the sytlized cover art for this book. There is a black and white, generally well known photo of each woman. I found this book after I'd spent most of a week listening to Robert Cray almost exclusively. My theory was that I should steep myself in blues music as a way of accessing more about the Indigo Guardian Angel. I kept having this really intense and somewhat eerie feeling that fabric for this piece was on its way to me; that is was actually going to be more than one piece. Wooooooo and then that's what happened. I received these. Wooooooo and woo some more!

